• Home
  • SOCRATES’ THINKING
    • News and comment
    • Editorial
  • About
  • US
    • Sportsocratic team
    • Contributors
  • Reviews
    • Adventures
    • Books
    • Places
  • Contributions
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Sportsocratic

Thoughts, ideas, opinions and postulations on sport and adventuring

  • Sport & society
    • Ethics & Values
    • History
    • Favourite photos
    • Cultural and social issues
    • Politics
    • Big questions
    • Sport fashion
      • Sartorialism and style
  • Wild sports
  • Silly stuff
  • Sports science
    • Research
    • Coaching
    • Innovation
    • HEALTH
  • The things that made me
  • Stories
    • General sporting stories
    • Waves of Pain
      • No Respect!
      • Death Wish at Fairy Bower
      • Fried nuts
      • The ocean is a trickster… especially Hawaii’s North Shore – Gas chambers bites the unwary!
      • Titus Kinimaka’s nightmare Christmas
      • Dix dumped – the trials of a self-confessed elite body surfer
      • The little surf that nearly ruined a promising career…
      • Rabbit killer – a master takes a caning at pipeline!
      • Death Wish at Fairy Bower
      • Easternmost memory – surfing in the wild at the end of the continent
      • Nothing ruins a good surf like a couple of blokes with automatic assault rifles…
      • Agony for Miki Dora
      • Smashed at Gas Chambers
      • Who was Europe’s first surfing woman? Introducing the wonderful Witch of Newbury.
      • A bad day at Palmy – surfies and clubbies at war!
      • When being a proven waterman is not enough!
      • The highs and lows of surfing Sunset Beach while competing at the Duke Kahanamoku Invitational
      • An American midnight surf – that goes very wrong!
  • What does it mean?
    • What is a snake?
    • What does “shag” mean?
    • What does “Freddy Jones” mean?
    • What does “hook and ladder” mean?
    • What does back walk-over mean?
  • Philosophers Sport Bar
    • Socrates and Aristotle debate football defence
    • Michel de Montaigne on coaching sports
    • Ancient philosophers discuss what makes the beautiful game beautiful! Laozi and Socrates get technical.

A-League goings on – “Bes” gets two weeks. Teenager gets “mandatory year. WTF?

October 30, 2017 By SOCRATES NEWS DESK Leave a Comment Filed Under: News and comment

The Besart Berisha suspension after last week’s A-League football game opens a huge can of worms, the way I see it.

If Berisha gets a two-week suspension for pushing a match official in the A League, how come a seventeen-year-old girl gets a twelve-month suspension for unsporting conduct toward an official in a regional third division game.

According to the soccer boffins, who I assume know the rules, a “normal” four-week suspension was reduced to a two-week suspension, in “Bes’s” case, with a further two-weeks held-over for the rest of the season. Apparently Berisha’s contrition, plus the fact that he voluntarily attended the disciplinary hearing and he had some good character references won him mercy from the panel.

The incident

Star striker “Bes” gets two weeks and might be lucky!

The facts of the Berisha matter are that the Melbourne star striker committed a dodgy tackle on an opponent and when the opponent’s team-mates arced up, an assistant ref took it upon himself to escort Berisha away from the scuffle to reduce the tension. The official placed his arm around Berisha and pushed him away from opposition players. Berisha put up with the childish man-handing for a few seconds, then turned and pushed the official’s arm away.

Firstly, the official should not have touched the player. Being a match official does not give you the right to touch anyone. Rule number one in the referee’s training manual should be, respect players and never touch them. If you want respect from players, then show them respect too!

Secondly, Berisha should not have responded by pushing the referee back. If he had said, “get your hands off me, please” it would have been an appropriate response but shoving back is a serious matter. Berisha deserved his two-match suspension. I would have given more. The A League, by treating the matter so lightly, says to players that, under certain circumstances, touching refs is okay. Well it’s not. Berisha should have gotten a longer suspension… and the official should have gotten a few weeks suspension plus some retraining, as well!

Teenager gets twelve months!

Which brings me to what I regard as a much more significant story. Early this season, a seventeen- year-old girl from regional New South Wales received a “mandatory” twelve months suspension for unsporting conduct towards a match official. The girl had numerous character references presented in letter form, the player herself wrote a letter of apology to the referee and she was willing to appear in person at a hearing to speak in her own defence. My understanding is that her presence was not required and that the letters written in her defence were of little consequence because, in matters such as this one, a minimum twelve months suspension is “mandatory.”

Not what you wanna see when you already have one!

Let’s get this out of the way early. The girl’s offense was a shocker and deserved serious consequences. None of her friends, supporters or fellow club members deny this. She lost it and spat in the direction of the referee. The offending projectile may have only landed at the official’s feet but spitting at someone is way out of line under any circumstances and the immediate red card and threat of being hauled up before a disciplinary committee to determine a significant suspension is a spot-on response. However, a “mandatory” suspension against an under-age person without consideration of mitigating circumstances is equally out of line. It’s completely unreasonable!

Firstly, the player in question was, at the time, a seventeen-year-old homeless student. How many homeless teenagers out there are managing to keep themselves in the education system? This was a couch-surfing kid managing to get herself up, out of bed, and off to college every day determined to build a better life for herself despite no home and no money.

Secondly, for all those who might want to say… “well, where are the girls parent?” Well, the girl might say the same thing. At the time of the incident the teenager had no family at all to support, feed, protect and house her. Luckily she did have supportive friends who offered her a bed and food.

Thirdly, the girl, at the time, had health problems.

Need I go further?

It is a damned miracle that this decent young kid was managing to feed herself and get herself to college most days without the support of any family and the fact that she was also playing an important role in a local soccer team was just fantastic for her and for the community. How many teenagers do you know who are getting on with life as successfully as this kid was, despite horrible circumstances.

Why are teenage girls treated more harshly than professionals?

So, she loses it in a soccer game and with no consideration of circumstances, no appearance in her own defence, an individual who is still legally a child is banned from soccer for twelve months.

Extenuating circumstances not considered!

A brief mention of the circumstances leading to her “losing it” on the pitch does not attempt to justify her behaviour but it does help to make the offense understandable. The girl, a striker, broke free of her last defender then pushed the ball past the goal keeper to score her first ever double in a match. Much to the surprise of the girl, players from both teams, the spectators, and several independent by-standers behind the goal the referee believed the goal-keeper’s claim that there had been a hand ball and so disallowed the goal and gave a free kick to the goalie.

Off-side calls, unfair challenge calls and many other foul calls in the box can generate debate and anger among players but, in the end, those kinds of calls are often line ball and while they might cause players to get pissed off, they aren’t taken personally. Telling a player that they hand-balled to score a goal is different. It’s personal. It’s calling the player a cheat! When the referee gave a free kick to the opposition instead of awarding a goal, then he was agreeing with the goalie that the girl had cheated. Lots of talented players would take the insult on the chin, rant quietly to themselves or maybe even have a bit of a whinge at the ref. This girl, on this occasion, perhaps sick to death of the world unjustifiably taking things away from her that she didn’t deserve to have taken away, lost it and misbehaved towards her accuser!

No-one… least of all the teenager herself… claimed that the behaviour was justified. A red card and a suspension were always going to happen. The referee for the game was no older than the girl in question and, as a volunteer, he has a right to expect that he will not be abused or disrespected. Whether he erred over disallowing the goal or not, his handling of the situation was both reasonable and competent. The problem I have, and the problem that others that know anything about this matter is, that the penalty was “mandatory”. Why were the circumstances such as the girls age, health, personal situation and good character not considered? A twelve month ban but with a percentage of the penalty “held-over” as happened in the Berisha case might have made sense.

What is the purpose of sport?  

The fact that an adult professional athlete who is reasonably well paid, has a good home, has a family and has what most would regard as an enviable life receives two weeks for unsporting behaviour and a homeless, powerless, moneyless, parentless child gets a year without any discussion is incomprehensible to me. In Berisha’s case it started with a nasty foul that he was responsible for. In the girl’s case, it started from what she thought should be a very special moment for her… a goal! This kid had never been called for a foul in her playing career. Some may argue that the girl’s offense was way worse. I think that that’s intolerant bullshit!

In a conversation I had with Ange Postecoglou, a while back, he said to me that one thing that really riles him is when someone says or does something that drives kids away from football. I agree with him.

Football isn’t about the Socceroos, or the A-League, or the World Cup, or the Premier League or snotty over-paid professional athletes. Football is about people playing a fun and healthy game that enables them to enrich their lives. Besart Berisha doesn’t really need football. Leo Messi doesn’t really need football. Christiano Renaldo doesn’t really need football either. This young girl, who has been rubbed out of the game, does need football. Football was one of the few positive elements in what was, at the time, a difficult life. She needed football but apparently football did not want her. No questions asked or answered. You’re out kid. We don’t care if you don’t come back.

I think it stinks!

Respect for match officials is one of the most sacred and important elements of organized sport. In my view, a sport’s capacity to be forgiving (especially when it comes to the errors of the young) is just as key an element. Where is the forgiveness here?

SOCRATES NEWS DESK

Here at Sportsocratic we are always on the lookout for the latest bits of news from the world of sports science that may be interesting or useful for our readers. If we hear that any boffins are onto something new and exciting and we think that you should know about it you will hear about it here! Regards... Socrates.

Support Sportsocratic

Thanks for reading this story! We appreciate your visit to Sportsocratic… and love providing alternative information, opinions and angles from the sporting world. The world of sport is so full of the same old stuff from the same old sources that it drives us nuts… and it makes our day giving voice to less orthodox views. If you appreciate our free service, give some thought to helping us out. It costs us big bucks to keep Sportsocratic going but, if our readers support us, our future is much more secure.

Help us to keep you entertained and informed… and enable Socrates to keep asking those big philosophical sporting questions.

Support Sportsocratic for as little as a $1 and we would love you to bits. It only takes a few seconds!

Support Us

Tagged With: A-League, football, red card, soccer, suspension, unsporting, yellow card

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

Outstanding achievement

Outstanding (but not well-known) sporting achievement

September 19, 2019 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

Everyone has heard of Kelly Slater and his bucket load of world surfing titles. Michael Jordan and his multitude of NBA titles are pretty common knowledge too. Michael Schumacher’s six world driver’s championships are pretty well known as well. Here is a sporting achievement all three would be jealous of. Manly surfer Greg Mossop has a sporting achievement that these three champions could only dream of and Mossop believes that, with a bit of luck, he could have done even better!

Rugby Trivia

Olympics Rugby Teams – Who are the greatest?

April 23, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

The rugby trivia question for the century! Which national rugby union team holds the record for the most Olympic gold medals in Rugby Union (the full-team fifteen a side game)?

Ethics and fairplay

Never cheated in my life!

November 19, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

What is cheating? Is cheating a black and white moral issue… or are there shades of gray. Socrates spent twenty years in the engine room of the beautiful game of rugby… the scrum. He loved being a rugby hooker. He reckons that being slap bang in the middle of sixteen enormous, sweating blokes desperate to secure possession of the ball for their team taught him quite a bit about the fine art of cheating… what it is… and what it isn’t…. and how it can be done. Here Socrates lifts the veil on aspects of the workings of the 1970’s and 80’s amateur rugby scrum revealing some of its secrets. In so doing he shows that cheating is not a simple moral issue. he also claims to haver never deliberately cheated. Do you believe him?

Sport and the question of ethics

November 13, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

“Come on. Get over it. Move on. It’s just a game!”

Most sports lovers have, at some stage of their sporting lives, experienced what they perceived to be a significant sporting injustice and had their complaints answered with just such a response. But is it “just a game?” Do injustices within the sporting realm have the potential to do real damage to individuals and to society. Socrates heard a story about a local sporting team who felt that they had been dudded by the organizers of their regional competition and he wondered whether their concerns about the perceived lack of fairness in their case and the potential consequences for all involved had any merit.

When Socrates heard former rugby referee and philosopher, Dr Simon Longstaff (Executive Director of The Ethics Centre), discussing the importance of ethics with great eloquence and passion on the radio he thought that he might be a good person to ask about whether ethics applies in sport and whether there are potential consequences for society when fair play in sport is sidestepped.

Simon was kind enough to agree to a chat. Click the pic to read the good stuff.

New surfing podcast

One of Australia’s greatest ever surfers – one of surfing’s greatest story tellers – “Rabbit” Bartholomew – talks to award winning journalist Tim Baker about life, surfing and stuff. Perfect listening for lockdown entertainment.

SOCRATES’ RECENT TWEETS

Tweets by Sportsocratic

professionalism

Priorities in times of Covid-19

April 14, 2020 By SOCRATES NEWS DESK Leave a Comment

Here is a story about a new kid in town who suddenly, as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, has to worry about how she will survive. At the same time, sports celebrities implore “loyal fans” to keep supporting their clubs financially. This kid…. and millions of others (many of them new kids in town) just WANT THEIR MONEY BACK. They need it! The elite sports leaders and many average punters come from totally different worlds. When someone asks the ones without jobs about how important the survival of professional sports teams is, I doubt that they have even given it any thought. They have more important things on their minds.

wisdom

Its just a job. Grass grows. Birds fly. Waves pound the sand. I beat people up. – Muhammad Ali

sport at mardi gras

Athletes in the LGBTQI Mardi Gras

March 12, 2019 By SOCRATES 2 Comments

Twenty-one different sports teams marched in this years Sydney Mardi Gras. That’s twenty-one groups of out and proud queer athletes. The LGBTQI community need to be “fearless” and queer athletes are no exception. Check out these fearless sporting clubs living it up on their night of night!

A life with horses

A life with horses – or Lulu in wonderland

August 8, 2018 By TIMOTHY EDWARDS Leave a Comment

It’s well known that playing sport can be a life-changing experience. For one mum, adventurer and businessperson, having a sporty pastime was more than life-changing. Lulu’s friendship with her horses has touched her and her daughter’s lives in a million ways and created a whole new life in an ever-changing wonderland for them both. But don’t think for a moment that their horses are the purpose built catalysts for their ideal lives! Its way more complex than that… and more respectful. Read on! It’s worth it!

wisdom

“Pressure? Pressure is a Messerschmidt up your arse. Playing cricket is not!”

Keith Miller

One of the greatest cricket “all-rounders” of all time, Keith Miller was not only an exceptional performer in multiple elements of test cricketing (batting, bowling and fielding) but he was also gifted in numerous other aspects of his life. Witty, entertaining, handsome, a renowned war time pilot and gifted Australian Rules Footballer, Miller was famed for calling a spade a spade and acknowledging that there was much more to life than elite sports. Having flown fighter bombers in the Second World War under life threatening circumstances he was not one to take the “pressure” of high level sport too seriously!

trivia

Here is a cracker of a trivia question.

Who was the college recruiting scout talking about when he said the following to his head coach.

“I’ve just seen a fat guy… who can play like the wind!”

Yup. The same guy who told people that just because they had shoes like his, it didn’t make them like him in any other way. Charles Wade Barkley.

Etymology

Where did the word canter come from?

August 8, 2018 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

A bit more horsey stuff for people who liked the story next door. Here is a cracker bit of etymology for all you word lovers (and horse lovers) out there. Where does the word canter come from? You’ll never guess in a million years! Click here to find out. It’s a beauty!

What does it mean?

What is Elvis leg?

Admit it. You’ve never heard of “Elvis leg,” have you? What the blazes is “Elvis leg?” As is the case with every other “What does it mean…” story we have ever posted, the answer is not directly related to the name itself. It is indirectly related to Elvis, though. Have a guess what the relationship is… then click here and check out whether your were correct. Find out for certain which sport uses this term and what it means.

What is a liberator?

Of course most you aviation buffs will think that a liberator is an American WW2 heavy bomber. Fair enough. But in a sporting context does it have a completely different meaning? Indeed it does. You are going to have to click here to find out what a liberator is and does in the world of sport.

Aphorisms, insights and wisdom

“The thing that’s depressing about tennis is that no matter how good I get I will never be as good as a wall.”

More perceptive sporting analysis from Mitch Hedberg, comic genius.

 

ebook

Phillip has returned to the south of India after eighteen years. But who is the young girl staying in his hotel? And what will he learn about his estranged brother through Inez, the Spanish backpacker?

To buy The Bangalore Test, John Campbell’s new ebook novella, just click the link.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

©2019 Sportsocratic