• Home
  • SOCRATES’ THINKING
    • News and comment
    • Editorial
  • About
  • US
    • Sportsocratic team
    • Contributors
  • Reviews
    • Adventures
    • Books
    • Places
  • Contributions
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Sportsocratic

Thoughts, ideas, opinions and postulations on sport and adventuring

  • Sport & society
    • Ethics & Values
    • History
    • Favourite photos
    • Cultural and social issues
    • Politics
    • Big questions
    • Sport fashion
      • Sartorialism and style
  • Wild sports
  • Silly stuff
  • Sports science
    • Research
    • Coaching
    • Innovation
    • HEALTH
  • The things that made me
  • Stories
    • General sporting stories
    • Waves of Pain
      • No Respect!
      • Death Wish at Fairy Bower
      • Fried nuts
      • The ocean is a trickster… especially Hawaii’s North Shore – Gas chambers bites the unwary!
      • Titus Kinimaka’s nightmare Christmas
      • Dix dumped – the trials of a self-confessed elite body surfer
      • The little surf that nearly ruined a promising career…
      • Rabbit killer – a master takes a caning at pipeline!
      • Death Wish at Fairy Bower
      • Easternmost memory – surfing in the wild at the end of the continent
      • Nothing ruins a good surf like a couple of blokes with automatic assault rifles…
      • Agony for Miki Dora
      • Smashed at Gas Chambers
      • Who was Europe’s first surfing woman? Introducing the wonderful Witch of Newbury.
      • A bad day at Palmy – surfies and clubbies at war!
      • When being a proven waterman is not enough!
      • The highs and lows of surfing Sunset Beach while competing at the Duke Kahanamoku Invitational
      • An American midnight surf – that goes very wrong!
  • What does it mean?
    • What is a snake?
    • What does “shag” mean?
    • What does “Freddy Jones” mean?
    • What does “hook and ladder” mean?
    • What does back walk-over mean?
  • Philosophers Sport Bar
    • Socrates and Aristotle debate football defence
    • Michel de Montaigne on coaching sports
    • Ancient philosophers discuss what makes the beautiful game beautiful! Laozi and Socrates get technical.

Scorers and a play-makers. Is there is difference?

July 4, 2017 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment Filed Under: Coaching, Sports science, Uncategorized

When coaches talk about the difference between a number 9 and a number 10 in soccer, a point-guard and a shooting-guard in basketball, a fly-half and a centre-three-quarter in rugby, a quarter-back and a running-back in American Football or a goal-attack and a goal-shooter in netball the focus tends to be on the differences in either the skill sets or the physical attributes of the players.

Stephanie Wood is definitely shorter and faster than her goal-scorer buddy Caitlin Bassett

Usually, netball goal-attackers are shorter and faster than their goal-shooting team-mates. Quarter-backs are much better passers than their running-back buddies. In soccer, number 9s might be stronger and have better shooting skills (off the head or foot) than their number 10 counterparts. Usually fly-halves will not have the pace or size of centre-three-quarter players but will have great vision and accurate passing skills.

Is it just about physical attributes and acquired skills?

Is it all about the physical attributes and skills of the players that determines their ideal roles? I might be getting into dodgy and subjective areas here but could it also be true that personality has a role to play in determining what players make the best scorers and who is more suited to the playmaker role? I think so.

I have been coaching and watching a range of sports for many years and it seems to me that some players take to the play-maker role more naturally than others… others who are no less valuable to their teams because they are such a natural scoring threat. Whether these tendencies are created in individuals through nature (their genetic make-up) or nurture (the entire sum of experiences of their lives) it still seems to me that the position we are most suited to in a sporting team is at least, to some degree, determined by our personality and personal motivations.

Is there a scorer’s or play-maker’s instinct?

Was Mike Jordan the greatest natural scorer of any sport of all time?

That’s not to say we should line up athletes, give them a personality assessment, then brand them as one specific kind of player until kingdom come. That would be way too simplistic. An individual’s tendency to want to be either a play-maker or a scorer could exist anywhere on a broad continuum. Some athletes might have an 80-20 preference towards scoring (putting them at the extreme end of the scale) while lots might have a 50-50 balance between their desire to be a play-maker or a scorer. Using basketball as an example, Mike Jordan would make a good example of an 80-20 scorer who was ideally suited to the shooting-guard role. While his gut instinct was to take on the opposition, directly, wherever possible, his ability to organize play could not be denied either. Steph Curry, the Golden State point-guard probably sits closer to the 50-50 split… something a little unusual in a point guard who might normally tend towards the play-maker role preference. Curry can swing back and forward between devastating natural scorer and play-organizer depending on the needs of the game. Every player, their personality, their motivations and their desires is a little different.

At the other end of the scale would be the 80-20 play-makers. There are players like Magic Johnson, in basketball, or the late-career Pele, in soccer, who were driven by the ambition to make their team-mates look great! When they wanted, they could be mercurial scorers, but it was the assist, in the end, that really turned them on!

Secondly, an athlete’s tendency towards preferring one style of play over the other might shift with age or with the learning of a new range of skills. I have known lots of kids in soccer who destroyed oppositions with their goal scoring ability early in life but discovered, as they matured, that they preferred working their mischief from the number 10 role then laying off to someone else to score the goals and grab the glory. Such players normally have enough scoring skill to bag their share of goals as well, when their team needs them to.

So, the personality situation is far from black and white. Athletes can have a strong, medium or weak preference for one style of play over the other. Also, that preference or tendency might change over time.

Does it matter?

Why should preference or personality tendency be a concern to coaches?

It seems to me that many talented athletes could be playing in positions that are not psychologically suited to them or their preferences… just because they have the right body, the right physical attributes and the right set of skills that the coach thinks he or she is looking for in a role. Technically skilful attacking mid-field players, that couldn’t find a team mate open if their lives depended on it, are as common as hell in soccer. When every cell of a player’s being is screaming out to beat your opponent and score it’s hard to be an effective play-maker. If such a player were driven by the overwhelming desire to put the ball in the back of the net, then I reckon they are in the wrong position. I know some awful number 10s who might make devastating number 9s or wingers. Such players often have good scoring averages but poor goal to assist ratios. By playing them out of position, their careers are being held back and the team is disadvantaged!

Is Curry a natural play-maker? I doubt it. I wonder how he would go if he played for a team that forced him into a purely play-maker role.

The Golden State Warriors basketball team is an interesting case. I suspect that there are lots of NBA teams where Steph Curry (Golden State’s superstar point-guard) would struggle to be as successful as he is. His GSW role of being part-time point-guard and part-time small shooting guard might not be possible in teams that don’t have such an abundance of play-making talent throughout the remainder of the roster. In other teams, he might continue to pull outstanding individual scoring numbers but I doubt whether the team would be as overall successful. An NBA coach with a roster full of great scorers but short-on for play-makers would not be making a smart move, in my view, by forking out millions for a player like Curry. What he or she needs is a player like Stockton! The same might apply in other sports. Some soccer, rugby or netball teams may not need a specialist play-maker if their team is full of players who love to set up their mates. But if you have a team in which every player just loves to score, coach, you better find an Aaron Mooy or Jonathon Thurston.

There must be thousands of basketball teams in the world where the most talented and natural scorer has managed to talk themselves into the point guard role. Why a coach would allow a team’s most obvious “go-to guy” to also be the team’s play-maker seems to me beyond comprehension. Why a natural scorer would want to negate their scoring talent by sitting back in an organizing role, I have no idea. To have a single player responsible for three-quarters of the team’s productivity (especially when some of those responsibilities are somewhat conflicting) doesn’t seem to make a lot of sense to me. It might work for the Golden State Warriors but they are a very special and unusual outfit where most of the roster are genuinely multi-faceted players. Few teams are so blessed.

When an instinctive play-maker and an instinctive scorer come together… wow!

In any sport, it’s great to find a natural scorer and natural play-maker partnership. The scary thing for opposition teams and opposition coaches when having to face up to a combination like Karl Malone and John Stockton is that, if you are silly enough to try to stop the scorer by stacking the defence on them, the brilliant play-maker will have plenty enough scoring ability to burn you for leaving him or her open. A great play-maker and scorer double-act has way too many options up their sleeves to be troubled by a basic defensive response.

We saw something similar last week-end with Bassett and Wood from the Sunshine Coast Lightening in the Netball Super League Grand Final giving nightmares to the Sydney Giants defenders. With super-scorer Bassett looking unstoppable drawing extra defence, play-maker Wood flicked her shooting switch on, forcing the defenders to come back to her, thus opening up Bassett again. Wood and Bassett were almost impossible to defend!

About behaviour

Everything about Zidane’s behaviour marked him as a natural play-maker! Note his eye-line!

How can coaches react to this personality issue. I don’t know. I’m not a psychologist. My guess would be that if a player’s behaviour, on the field, court or at practice gave a strong indication that they have a natural tendency to want to attack their opponents goal or try-line then don’t be suckered into forcing them into a play-maker role no matter how appropriate their skills or shape might seem for that role. Every team needs players who lust to “find the back of the net” and to place them elsewhere seems wasteful to me. I would add that if they are desperate to score it seems likely to me that they would stuff up the play-maker role, often, anyway. The counter is also probably true. If you have a player that looks and seems like a scorer but behaves more like a play-maker my tip would be to shift them back deeper. They will more than likely continue to score for your team from a deeper position but will also bless your team and their team-mates with lots of assists.

The moral to the story? When constructing a balanced team, coaches need to think a little further than the traditional skills, physical attributes criteria when deciding on positional responsibilities and making team selections. I reckon coaches need to think about raw psychological make-up of players as well. Some athletes have a natural tendency to want to score and others prefer to create. When an athlete is pushed into an inappropriate role they, and the team, will suffer.

SOCRATES

Short, fat, slow, uncoordinated and clumsy, ancient Athenian Socrates had very few of the physical quality required of the elite athlete. He did have, on the other hand, a better than average brain between his ears and a mouth that could talk opposing players, referees and coaches half into their graves. Socrates, as a sport analyst, is what the world needs and misses. He is an opinionated so-and-so that actually thinks deeply about sport and adventuring and likes nothing better than provoking others into deep thought. Socrates is the antithesis of the sporting jock or the West Sydney soccer supporter.

Support Sportsocratic

Thanks for reading this story! We appreciate your visit to Sportsocratic… and love providing alternative information, opinions and angles from the sporting world. The world of sport is so full of the same old stuff from the same old sources that it drives us nuts… and it makes our day giving voice to less orthodox views. If you appreciate our free service, give some thought to helping us out. It costs us big bucks to keep Sportsocratic going but, if our readers support us, our future is much more secure.

Help us to keep you entertained and informed… and enable Socrates to keep asking those big philosophical sporting questions.

Support Sportsocratic for as little as a $1 and we would love you to bits. It only takes a few seconds!

Support Us

Tagged With: Cailtlin Basset, john stockton, Michael Jordan, natural, Play-maker, scorer, Steph Curry, Stephanie Wood, Zidane

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

sporting life

Their sporting life – A journalist’s story

April 7, 2021 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

“Bill” could have been a great rugby player… but he was more interested in other things. Do people display characteristics of their personal and working lives through their performances on the sporting field? Socrates describes the sporting life of one of his favorite people, and shows how the skill and character of one of Australia’s best journalists was always on show, even as a young man, whether on the rugby field, the basketball court or even on a quiet country headland when threatened with fisticuff by a big bloke wearing a blue uniform. Get “Bill’s” story here. Click the pic!

SOCRATES’ RECENT TWEETS

Tweets by Sportsocratic

Rugby Trivia

Olympics Rugby Teams – Who are the greatest?

April 23, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

The rugby trivia question for the century! Which national rugby union team holds the record for the most Olympic gold medals in Rugby Union (the full-team fifteen a side game)?

Ethics and fairplay

Never cheated in my life!

November 19, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

What is cheating? Is cheating a black and white moral issue… or are there shades of gray. Socrates spent twenty years in the engine room of the beautiful game of rugby… the scrum. He loved being a rugby hooker. He reckons that being slap bang in the middle of sixteen enormous, sweating blokes desperate to secure possession of the ball for their team taught him quite a bit about the fine art of cheating… what it is… and what it isn’t…. and how it can be done. Here Socrates lifts the veil on aspects of the workings of the 1970’s and 80’s amateur rugby scrum revealing some of its secrets. In so doing he shows that cheating is not a simple moral issue. he also claims to haver never deliberately cheated. Do you believe him?

Sport and the question of ethics

November 13, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

“Come on. Get over it. Move on. It’s just a game!”

Most sports lovers have, at some stage of their sporting lives, experienced what they perceived to be a significant sporting injustice and had their complaints answered with just such a response. But is it “just a game?” Do injustices within the sporting realm have the potential to do real damage to individuals and to society. Socrates heard a story about a local sporting team who felt that they had been dudded by the organizers of their regional competition and he wondered whether their concerns about the perceived lack of fairness in their case and the potential consequences for all involved had any merit.

When Socrates heard former rugby referee and philosopher, Dr Simon Longstaff (Executive Director of The Ethics Centre), discussing the importance of ethics with great eloquence and passion on the radio he thought that he might be a good person to ask about whether ethics applies in sport and whether there are potential consequences for society when fair play in sport is sidestepped.

Simon was kind enough to agree to a chat. Click the pic to read the good stuff.

matildas

Aivi Luik interview – Matilda unsung hero

February 6, 2020 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

In pub discussions about the Australian women’s football team’s most remarkable player the name Aivi Luik is not often the first one to come up. Socrates thinks that this might be a mistake and that the value of this remarkable athlete might be under-recognized. Check out her record of achievment in almost every corner of the football world. USA, Canada, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, United Kingdom, Spain, Australia. MVP awards. Championships. All star team selections. She has had a remarkable career by anyone’s standards and is still playing at her best at 34! With Luik and her fellow Matildas in camp preparing for their Olympic Games qualifying series matches against China, Thailand and Taiwan this week Socrates was grateful that she found time to answer some questions about her footballing life. Press here for the Aivi Luik interview – a must for all sports fans, especially ambitious young athletes considering overseas careers.

Outstanding achievement

Outstanding (but not well-known) sporting achievement

September 19, 2019 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

Everyone has heard of Kelly Slater and his bucket load of world surfing titles. Michael Jordan and his multitude of NBA titles are pretty common knowledge too. Michael Schumacher’s six world driver’s championships are pretty well known as well. Here is a sporting achievement all three would be jealous of. Manly surfer Greg Mossop has a sporting achievement that these three champions could only dream of and Mossop believes that, with a bit of luck, he could have done even better!

New surfing podcast

One of Australia’s greatest ever surfers – one of surfing’s greatest story tellers – “Rabbit” Bartholomew – talks to award winning journalist Tim Baker about life, surfing and stuff. Perfect listening for lockdown entertainment.

professionalism

Priorities in times of Covid-19

April 14, 2020 By SOCRATES NEWS DESK Leave a Comment

Here is a story about a new kid in town who suddenly, as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, has to worry about how she will survive. At the same time, sports celebrities implore “loyal fans” to keep supporting their clubs financially. This kid…. and millions of others (many of them new kids in town) just WANT THEIR MONEY BACK. They need it! The elite sports leaders and many average punters come from totally different worlds. When someone asks the ones without jobs about how important the survival of professional sports teams is, I doubt that they have even given it any thought. They have more important things on their minds.

wisdom

Its just a job. Grass grows. Birds fly. Waves pound the sand. I beat people up. – Muhammad Ali

sport at mardi gras

Athletes in the LGBTQI Mardi Gras

March 12, 2019 By SOCRATES 2 Comments

Twenty-one different sports teams marched in this years Sydney Mardi Gras. That’s twenty-one groups of out and proud queer athletes. The LGBTQI community need to be “fearless” and queer athletes are no exception. Check out these fearless sporting clubs living it up on their night of night!

A life with horses

A life with horses – or Lulu in wonderland

August 8, 2018 By TIMOTHY EDWARDS Leave a Comment

It’s well known that playing sport can be a life-changing experience. For one mum, adventurer and businessperson, having a sporty pastime was more than life-changing. Lulu’s friendship with her horses has touched her and her daughter’s lives in a million ways and created a whole new life in an ever-changing wonderland for them both. But don’t think for a moment that their horses are the purpose built catalysts for their ideal lives! Its way more complex than that… and more respectful. Read on! It’s worth it!

wisdom

“Pressure? Pressure is a Messerschmidt up your arse. Playing cricket is not!”

Keith Miller

One of the greatest cricket “all-rounders” of all time, Keith Miller was not only an exceptional performer in multiple elements of test cricketing (batting, bowling and fielding) but he was also gifted in numerous other aspects of his life. Witty, entertaining, handsome, a renowned war time pilot and gifted Australian Rules Footballer, Miller was famed for calling a spade a spade and acknowledging that there was much more to life than elite sports. Having flown fighter bombers in the Second World War under life threatening circumstances he was not one to take the “pressure” of high level sport too seriously!

trivia

Here is a cracker of a trivia question.

Who was the college recruiting scout talking about when he said the following to his head coach.

“I’ve just seen a fat guy… who can play like the wind!”

Yup. The same guy who told people that just because they had shoes like his, it didn’t make them like him in any other way. Charles Wade Barkley.

Etymology

Where did the word canter come from?

August 8, 2018 By SOCRATES Leave a Comment

A bit more horsey stuff for people who liked the story next door. Here is a cracker bit of etymology for all you word lovers (and horse lovers) out there. Where does the word canter come from? You’ll never guess in a million years! Click here to find out. It’s a beauty!

What does it mean?

What is Elvis leg?

Admit it. You’ve never heard of “Elvis leg,” have you? What the blazes is “Elvis leg?” As is the case with every other “What does it mean…” story we have ever posted, the answer is not directly related to the name itself. It is indirectly related to Elvis, though. Have a guess what the relationship is… then click here and check out whether your were correct. Find out for certain which sport uses this term and what it means.

What is a liberator?

Of course most you aviation buffs will think that a liberator is an American WW2 heavy bomber. Fair enough. But in a sporting context does it have a completely different meaning? Indeed it does. You are going to have to click here to find out what a liberator is and does in the world of sport.

Aphorisms, insights and wisdom

“The thing that’s depressing about tennis is that no matter how good I get I will never be as good as a wall.”

More perceptive sporting analysis from Mitch Hedberg, comic genius.

 

ebook

Phillip has returned to the south of India after eighteen years. But who is the young girl staying in his hotel? And what will he learn about his estranged brother through Inez, the Spanish backpacker?

To buy The Bangalore Test, John Campbell’s new ebook novella, just click the link.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

©2019 Sportsocratic